By the 1980s, The Year of Living Dangerously's Peter Weir had developed a reputation as an Australian director of empathy and intelligence, but 1985's Witness, his first American feature, brought him to a wider audience, resulting in a box office hit, two Oscar wins, and the sole nomination to date for Harrison Ford, who gives a warm and sensitive performance as a hardened Philadelphia detective who softens upon meeting an Amish widow.
The story begins when Samuel, an Amish boy (seven-year-old Lukas Haas, instantly endearing), witnesses a murder in a train station men's room. He tells his mom (Kelly McGillis, whose persuasive performance would lead to Tony Scott's Top Gun the following year), and Ford's John Book questions him about what he saw, revealing a strong rapport with children.
That continues when he brings mother and son to the precinct for a formal statement. Without saying a word, Samuel indicates, by pointing at a newspaper clipping in a trophy case, that he saw McFee (Danny Glover, Places in the Heart), a narcotics officer, slit an undercover cop's throat. Book tells his superior, Schaeffer (Josef Sommer), but when McFee attempts to gun Book down in a parking garage, he realizes his boss is dirty, too–and that Samuel's life is in danger.
The film turns high concept when the injured Book whisks the two from his sister's house (she's played by Patti LuPone) to their Lancaster, Pennsylvania farm, but when he tries to drive away, he passes out and and crashes his car, so Rachel, who lives with her father-in-law, Eli (Czech opera singer Jan Rubeš), takes him in and secures medical treatment. Book enters an alien world without electricity or any modern conveniences, but once recovered, he realizes it isn't safe to return to the city, so he makes an effort to blend in by helping to raise a barn and other tasks that call on Ford's former career as a carpenter.
In the process, he and Rachel grow close. Weir and cinematographer John Seale, an Oscar winner for The English Patient, have cited Vermeer as an influence on the honeyed glow of their chaste, yet erotically-charged encounters, culminating in a sequence in which they dance by lamplight to a cover of Sam Cooke's "Wonderful World," a song Ford selected.
The turncoat cops eventually disturb their idyll, and the ending plays like a cross between Lost Horizon and Brief Encounter. The entire cast, including ballet dancer Alexander Gudonov and Viggo Mortensen, in his first studio picture, rises to the occasion, and Weir makes a scenario that could have played like comedy both touching and convincing. The screenplay, which was adapted from an unproduced episode of Gunsmoke, resulted in an Oscar for Earl W. Wallace and William Kelley, which makes sense if you think of Witness as a western (novelist Pamela Wallace, Earl’s wife, cowrote the story).
In 2023, the year he announced his retirement, Peter Weir received an Honorary Oscar in recognition of his four nominations for Best Director, in addition to a catalog filled with classics, like Picnic at Hanging Rock and Gallipoli, but Witness was the film where he proved he could infuse Hollywood filmmaking with restraint and romanticism.
Why should public and academic libraries add this classic thriller to their film ollections?
Peter Weir’s Witness is both a gripping thriller and a poignant character study that bridges mainstream appeal with artistic sophistication. Its thoughtful exploration of violence, cultural isolation, and moral integrity makes it a strong addition to public library collections that serve adult audiences interested in classic cinema, crime dramas, or films with deeper ethical questions. For academic libraries, Witness stands out as a Hollywood film that incorporates foreign directorial sensibilities—Weir’s Australian roots are evident in the film’s restraint, pacing, and rich visual language. With its Oscar-winning screenplay and career-defining performance by Harrison Ford, it also serves as a useful title in collections supporting film studies, American culture, and religion or ethics-related programming.
What courses could use Witness?
Witness can be used across a variety of disciplines. In Film Studies, it offers rich material for analyzing genre blending (crime thriller meets romantic drama meets western), cinematography influenced by fine art (notably Vermeer), and cross-cultural narrative techniques. In American Studies or Cultural Anthropology, it provides a look at Amish life and contrasts urban and rural values in Reagan-era America. In Religious Studies or Ethics, the film sparks discussion around pacifism, justice, and the moral compromises demanded by modern society.
Enjoyed this review? Subscribe to Video Librarian today for access to over 40,000 pages of film resources tailored for librarians, educators, and non-theatrical audiences.