Peter McDowell (I Dream of Dorothy) spent over a decade working on this first-person documentary about his older brother, Jimmy, who died in Vietnam at the age of 24. Peter, who was only five at the time, assumed he was a casualty of war, but he didn't know for sure, so he sets out to solve the mystery, explaining that Jimmy’s death created a veil of secrecy and sadness over his middle-class family in suburban Champaign-Urbana, Illinois.
High school friends remember Jimmy's love of music and movies. After graduation, he went to the University of Chicago, but dropped out during his junior year and was drafted shortly afterward. He would have preferred to be a conscientious objector, but his family talked him out of it. After basic training in California and Texas, he was sent to Vietnam in 1970.
Despite the dangers, he found a sense of purpose in Vietnam, and even after being mustered home later that year, he couldn’t wait to go back--for reasons he couldn't clearly articulate--and so he returned as a civilian. He had originally intended to continue his studies, but instead found work at a law firm catering to American soldiers. He told friends he was drawn to the sex, the drugs, the food, and the music. He aimed to "experience hedonistic pleasures like never before.”
As Peter comes to discover, Jimmy had also fallen in love. After talking to his friends in the States, he travels to France and Vietnam. Along the way, he meets with a French journalist who befriended Jimmy and the American doctor who treated him. Though his parents believed he died of a heroin overdose, that wasn’t the case, and the truth proves both more prosaic and more depressing, because it could have been prevented if Jimmy had only sought medical treatment sooner.
Finally, Peter meets with a Vietnamese-American woman who believes that Jimmy was gay, even if he never described himself that way. In fact, he would tell people she was his girlfriend. Though Jimmy never came out, Peter didn’t feel he had a choice. If his Catholic mother, Ellen, expressed surprise and disappointment at first, she would become a steadfast ally.
Peter’s father, Austin, who had been diagnosed with Alzheimer's when he began work on his documentary, appears briefly on screen, but passed away in 2013. Jimmy in Saigon documents his journey into his brother's life, but since he shares most everything he learns with his mother, it's about Ellen's journey, too, even if she doesn't accompany him on his travels.
It isn't clear if she takes comfort in knowing that her oldest son didn't die from a drug overdose after all, and nor is it clear how she would have reacted if he had come out to her in the 1960s. Peter ends by saying that he feels he has helped his family to heal (his brother, John, also worked on the film). We can't know for certain that this is true, but it does seem to have brought him closer to his mother, and mostly to a sense of peace, knowing that Jimmy might have been a kindred spirit. Recommended.
Why should public and academic libraries add this biography to their collections?
Jimmy in Saigon offers a personal perspective on the Vietnam War era, told not through battlefield accounts but through the hidden life of an American soldier who stayed behind. By tracing Jimmy McDowell’s story as both a veteran and a gay man navigating love and secrecy abroad, the film expands the historical record in ways that are often missing from mainstream narratives. For public libraries, it provides an accessible entry point into LGBTQ history and family storytelling that resonates with general audiences. For academic libraries, the documentary enriches collections on military history, queer identity, and U.S. cultural memory, making it a valuable resource for research and community programming alike.
Can Jimmy in Saigon be used in courses on U.S. History, Gender Studies, or Queer Studies?
Yes. The film’s intersection of personal testimony, archival material, and cultural context makes it highly adaptable for the classroom. In U.S. history courses, it prompts discussion about the Vietnam War’s lasting impact on soldiers and families, including those whose lives unfolded outside conventional narratives. In gender and queer studies, the film illuminates the challenges of LGBTQ identity in the mid-20th century and how silence shaped entire communities. Faculty can use Jimmy in Saigon to spark conversations about intersectionality, erasure, and the importance of recovering marginalized voices in the historical record.
Enjoyed this review? Subscribe to Video Librarian today for access to over 40,000 pages of film resources tailored for librarians, educators, and non-theatrical audiences.