Joan Baez: I Am a Noise offers an especially reflective look at singer/songwriter and activist Joan Baez.
In the 2023 documentary from Miri Navasky, Maeve O'Boyle, and Karen O'Connor, the co-directors use Joan's final 2019 tour as a framing device. In the film, she makes it clear that she doesn't take her 60-year career as a working artist for granted. She exercises and meets regularly with a vocal coach to ensure that she can deliver the robust performances fans expect, though she acknowledges that she can't sound exactly like she did when she was young.
As Joan remembers it, her social consciousness came before her singing because her Quaker parents instilled it in daughters Pauline, Joan, and Mimi. She wasn't immune to prejudice, though, since kids made fun of her Mexican heritage. Fortunately, she had no problem standing up for herself. In archival footage, Pauline, who passed away in 2016, also offers her thoughts about their childhood, while Hannah Shykind voices passages from Joan's diary alongside home video, audio from therapy sessions, and animated illustrations (the title comes from a line in her diary, "I am not a saint, I am a noise").
Her entire family was musical, but only Joan and Mimi pursued careers in music. It didn't take Joan long to find fame as she went from coffee shops to the Newport Folk Festival to the cover of TIME magazine. By 19, she was the face of the folk music movement, but it generated more tension than pride. With Mimi, it led to competition until Joan's younger sister met Richard Fariña, with whom she formed a duo, but she never regained her footing after his accidental death in 1966 (she passed away in 2001). For a time, Joan formed a duo with Bob Dylan, with whom she sang when they toured together.
If Joan was more famous than Mimi, she found out what it was like to be in another musician's shadow when Dylan's fame eclipsed hers. She found a more lasting relationship with activist David Harris, with whom she had a son, but they eventually grew apart. If Gabriel felt neglected, he went on to play drums in his mother's band, and they seem to have made their peace.
As a musician, Joan would reteam with Dylan on the Rolling Thunder Revue tour, which was a critical and commercial success but involved a lot of partying and a lot of drugs. "Too much Quaalude," as she puts it. "That was my drug of choice for eight years." It isn't clear how she cleaned up her act, but she appears to have stayed on the straight and narrow ever since.
The co-directors also look at Joan's struggles with mental health and her involvement with nonviolent movements, which made her feel useful, though when the Vietnam War came to an end, she was at a loss. Activism, for her, wasn't just about conviction; it gave her life purpose. Without something to protest, she felt useless, leading to musical and marketing decisions she would come to regret, though she learned from her mistakes and ended her career on her own terms.
By focusing on Joan's reflections and impressions, along with video and other material featuring family members rather than famous names, Joan Baez: I Am a Noise proves more intimate and emotionally revealing than most biographical portraits. Recommended.
Why should public libraries add Joan Baez: I Am a Noise to their documentary and music collections?
Joan Baez: I Am a Noise offers more than a straightforward overview of a celebrated musician's career. Through Joan's diaries, home videos, therapy recordings, family recollections, and reflections during her final tour, the documentary gives patrons an unusually intimate look at the person behind the public figure. Music fans will find plenty of material about her rise through the folk movement and relationships with figures like Bob Dylan, while the emphasis on her family and private life makes the film accessible even to viewers who aren't already familiar with her work.
The documentary should also appeal to patrons interested in the intersection of music and social activism. Joan's commitment to nonviolent movements is presented as fundamental to her identity rather than simply another chapter in her career, giving libraries opportunities to connect the film with programming or collections focused on folk music, American cultural history, protest movements, and influential women in music.
How can educators use Joan Baez: I Am a Noise in music, history, and cultural studies courses?
The documentary has clear applications across several academic subjects. Music and cultural studies courses can use Joan's career to explore the American folk movement, the pressures of fame, and the relationship between musicians and the social movements surrounding their work. Her experiences with Bob Dylan and the Rolling Thunder Revue also provide material for discussions of how musical movements evolve and how artists navigate changing audiences and careers.
History and social studies courses may find particular value in the documentary's treatment of Joan's activism and commitment to nonviolence. At the same time, its use of diaries, archival footage, home video, therapy recordings, and animation gives film and media studies students an opportunity to examine how documentary filmmakers construct a biographical portrait from different kinds of primary and personal material. Rather than concentrating solely on Joan Baez as a famous musician, I Am a Noise gives students a way to consider how public history and private memory can combine to tell the story of a life.
Enjoyed this review? Subscribe to Video Librarian today for access to over 40,000 pages of film resources tailored for librarians, educators, and non-theatrical audiences.
