Slave Reparations

The argument in favor of the payment of compensation to the descendants of slaves is presented in straightforward style in this two-part documentary offering an overview of the rationale behind the idea and addressing objections that have been raised, as well as suggesting ways in which such a project might be implemented. The format is extremely simple--a mere stringing together of interview excerpts featuring various proponents of slave reparations (academics, journalists, activists, ministers, and politicians)--and no real attempt is made to present dissenting opinions in any coherent manner. In fact, each segment opens with a printed question, against which major objections are spoken by supposedly “ordinary” citizens (whose voices frequently overlap in a manufactured sort of cacophony) followed by comments from the aforementioned interviewees, who dispose of these negative remarks with cool efficiency. Obviously, Slave Reparations isn't a balanced, objective treatment of the issue; it's effectively a recruitment film for the cause. Nonetheless, by having the arguments in favor of the concept expressed so articulately and succinctly, the film can be used to generate discussion and debate, and as such it may prove to be a good educational tool. On that basis, this is recommended, with reservations. Aud: H, C, P. (F. Swietek)