The Discoverer of the Discoverers gives viewers a glimpse of a family in Benin as they recount the story of their ancestor who, in 1548, is said to have been the first to meet Portuguese explorers on their shores. The tale has been preserved through artifacts, oral tradition, and ritual, and the film documents how the tradition is performed and passed down to younger generations. The tale describes the moment of contact as a kind of “discovery” in reverse, positioning their ancestor as the one who found the Europeans rather than the other way around. Their narrative is shared with visiting filmmakers, and the camera observes the ceremonial retelling alongside fragments of everyday life in the community. The family celebrates their ancestor’s role while crowning a new “king”.
In spite of many festival accolades, The Discoverer of Discoverers doesn’t quite achieve the impact it seems to be reaching for, often prioritizing artsy cinematography over a deeper transfer of information and culture. There are glimpses of fascinating voodoo traditions that hint at a richer film, but they remain too few and far between—I only wish the documentary had leaned more into this subject, as the religions of Benin deserve closer attention. The director’s choice to leave much unsaid in a “kinda makes you think” manner risks glossing over the very specific historical and cultural realities at hand: we’re looking at descendants of some of the first trans-Atlantic slave traders who gave the Portuguese the keys to what we now call the Triangular Trade. The somber soundtrack and deliberately slowed footage feel more like an effort to stretch out limited content than an honest attempt to grapple with the historical moment, the family, or the city of Whydah itself. With more focus and a tighter commitment to its subject, this could have been a remarkable indie short about a rare conjunction of culture and history. Instead, its ambition to impress on the festival circuit leaves it feeling like form has outweighed function. Optional purchase.
Should libraries and classrooms add The Discoverer of Discoverers to their collections?
This documentary may be of interest to libraries and classrooms that want to spark discussion around African history, colonialism, and the ways film itself interprets cultural narratives. While it has clear limitations in depth and execution, its unique lens on Benin and its connection to the transatlantic slave trade may still make it worth including in larger collections. For academic libraries in particular, the film works best when framed as a conversation starter rather than a definitive historical resource.
Is this documentary useful for teaching African history?
The Discoverer of Discoverers does not provide the comprehensive historical overview that an instructor might expect for a classroom screening on its own. Instead, it can function as a supplementary piece—useful for analyzing how filmmakers represent sensitive cultural and historical material. Paired with primary sources or more detailed historical documentaries, it can help students critically engage with questions of representation, authorship, and ethics in film, while still introducing them to the context of Benin’s religious and historical landscape.
Enjoyed this review? Subscribe to Video Librarian today for access to over 40,000 pages of film resources tailored for librarians, educators, and non-theatrical audiences.