Peabody Award-winning documentarian Kim A. Snyder's The Librarians, which aired on PBS stations as part of Independent Lens, examines the rise of book bans in the United States. They aren’t just an assault on the health and safety of dedicated professionals trying to serve their communities, but on democracy itself.
Snyder (Newtown, Death by Numbers) builds her film around a book ban list, initiated by Fort Worth Representative Matt Krause and supported by Governor Greg Abbott, to remove 850 books dealing with race, sexuality, and political organizing from public schools, including books by award-winning authors Ta-nehisi Coates and Isabel Wilkerson, two among many Black authors. Non-profit parental rights organization Moms for Liberty has played a vital role in the process.
Beyond interviews, news footage, relevant film clips, and stirring passages from banned books, Snyder documents national librarian conferences where participants share their concerns and heated school board meetings, mostly in Texas, including a closed-door gathering in which a Granbury superintendent warns librarians about the consequences of noncompliance.
Fired librarians in the film compare the bans to those of the McCarthy and Nazi eras, while students who formed a banned book club cite Ray Bradbury’s dystopian novel Fahrenheit 451 (Snyder includes clips from François Truffaut’s adaptation). They find it ironic that the same Texas district banning books would assign one so clearly opposed to censorship.
Snyder also looks at bans in Florida, Louisiana, and New Jersey. Conservative parents and school board members use words like “vulgar" and “pornographic" to describe books with LGBTQ themes, even a fact-based children’s book about penguins.
Some of the smaller-town librarians fear for their lives as they’ve been targeted by extremists who wield Christianity as a weapon, even as many librarians are equally devout. Louisiana librarian Amanda Jones, who recounts her ordeal in the book That Librarian: The Fight Against Book Banning in America, was driven to carry a weapon and to use an alias online.
Snyder proves that the entire effort is coordinated, not least since the campaigns follow the same playbook, no matter the community. While Moms for Liberty claims to be a grass roots organization, they receive funding from the Heritage Foundation and other dark money entities. They don’t just aim to ban books in schools and public libraries, but to help elect right-wing candidates by pushing out progressives, taking over school boards, and restricting further civil liberties.
The director incorporates powerful moments, many involving meetings where pastors, parents, and students argue for the power of inclusive books. This includes Weston Brown, the ostracized gay son of a fundamentalist Christian activist, who returns to Granbury to speak at a school board meeting on behalf of books that help LGBTQ students to feel less alone.
Snyder makes a strong case that book bans benefit no one, especially the vulnerable, and that if allowed to proliferate, they can lead to other forms of censorship that make communities less safe. She ends on an optimistic note by showing the difference ordinary citizens can make when they organize to resist bans by protesting, attending and speaking at public meetings, running for school board, and filing lawsuits rooted in the principles of the First and Fourteenth Amendments. Highly recommended for anyone concerned about free speech and democratic principles.
Which library audiences should see this book banning and free speech documentary?
The Librarians would be a strong fit for public and academic libraries serving patrons interested in current events, censorship, education policy, and First Amendment issues. Its focus on the rise of book bans and the experiences of librarians on the front lines makes it especially relevant for communities engaged in conversations about intellectual freedom and access to information. Libraries with active programming around civic engagement, social justice, or contemporary political issues will find this documentary particularly valuable, as it speaks directly to the challenges many institutions are currently facing. While the subject matter may feel urgent and, at times, unsettling, it is precisely that immediacy that will resonate with patrons seeking to better understand the cultural and political climate surrounding libraries today.
Is this documentary a good choice for community screenings or discussion-based programming?
Yes, especially for libraries and organizations interested in fostering dialogue around censorship, education, and democratic participation. The Librarians offers a timely and often emotional look at the impact of book bans, providing a strong foundation for post-screening discussions. Its inclusion of multiple perspectives—librarians, students, parents, and activists—creates natural entry points for conversation, whether focused on policy, personal experience, or broader societal implications. The film pairs well with panels, community forums, or reading programs centered on banned books or intellectual freedom, and it can serve as a catalyst for meaningful engagement on local and national issues. Its concluding emphasis on civic action also makes it a particularly effective choice for programming aimed at encouraging community involvement and awareness.
Enjoyed this review? Subscribe to Video Librarian today for access to over 40,000 pages of film resources tailored for librarians, educators, and non-theatrical audiences.