Elementary: The First Season

The second new series to re-imagine Sherlock Holmes for the 21st century stars Jonny Lee Miller as Sherlock, a recovering drug addict (and genius) who moves to New York following rehab, and Lucy Liu as Joan Watson, a former surgeon turned sober companion hired to help him stay drug free. Miller's Holmes is no less abrasive than Benedict Cumberbatch's interpretation in the BBC show Sherlock—and no less brilliant. The series opens strong with Holmes playing the misanthrope to keep emotional connections at a distance, but as the episodes unfold, Miller brings out added depths and dimensions to the character, Liu carves out a new take on Watson as a medical professional who discovers an affinity for detective work, and the seemingly disparate pair create a working friendship and partnership. Aidan Quinn also shines as police captain Toby Gregson, who understands both Holmes' abilities and limitations, and the show nicely explores their mutual (and sometimes wary) respect. Despite Holmes' protests, the ghost of addiction (and accompanying feelings of guilt, shame, and desire) hangs over many of the episodes, especially as the legacy of both Irene Adler and Prof. Moriarty are incorporated into Sherlock's New York orbit. Compiling all 23 episodes from the 2012-13 debut season, extras include behind-the-scenes featurettes and a set tour with Liu. Highly recommended. (S. Axmaker)