In recent years, socialism has entered the zeitgeist. Politicians like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez identify as socialists, and it is used as a slur to condemn people with certain political leanings. The Big Scary “S” Word dives into the influence of socialism in the United States.
One thing that can be said about Yael Bridge’s film is that it is ambitious. In its 82 minutes, Bridge involves intellectual giants such as Cornel West, Richard Wolff, Naomi Klein, and others to discuss socialism’s role in the American landscape. Attention is given to the historical development of the ideology in America, as well as current society.
The film has a lot to say, yet it suffers from this ambition. It is often disjointed and hard to follow, as it jumps from stories set in the present day to historical framings and then back and forth again. Had Bridge focused instead on current socialists, instead of providing a syllabus for Socialist Evolution 101, the film would be a lot more effective.
One striking moment involves politician Lee Carter, a representative of the Virginia House of Delegates who has views many consider socialist. During a meeting, fellow delegate Mark Keam flashes the hammer and sickle on a laptop while Carter is speaking. This violation of decorum encapsulates Lee’s life as a politician: despite his intentions, he’ll forever be labeled a socialist, which many people equate immediately with…less than kind things.
The Scary S Word has a lot for viewers to digest. It would work better as a series of stories, yet it still has much to say. A strong optional purchase. Aud, C, P.