Heather Shaner is a lifelong public defender living and working in Washington, DC. Her more than forty years of experience have put her in the room with everyone from repeat drunk drivers to muggers to murderers. You’d think there wouldn’t be many things left to surprise such an experienced and successful defense lawyer, but fate has a way of throwing curveballs. Shaner, an outspoken progressive and long-time Democrat, is informed that she will be defending several people who took part in the Capitol invasion on January 6, 2021. For the first time in her career, she’s not sure if she can meet her clients where they are, but –hard-headed as ever– Shaner meets the challenge with her chest held high.
Public Defender is a fascinating documentary. Its obvious political slant may dampen general appeal in some places (as well as provoke “of course you have blue hair and pronouns” jokes), but for those interested in the legal process and court cases, this will be an easy hurdle to jump. How the documentarian managed to get such intimate contact with all of its subjects is astounding. While very pop-doc in its styling, Public Defender serves as an incredible glimpse into the world of misinformation and populist culture wars, almost an exposé. It cuts through the noise, centering on the idea that we are all people, and the things that divide us are much smaller and less important than we are led to believe.
Library patrons or students interested in the events of January 6th will have a vested interest in watching this documentary. Public Defender would also be an interesting addition to introductory law classes: I don’t think I’ve ever seen such an excellent non-fiction examination of the moral and political challenges that face defense lawyers in America, especially public defenders. Library patrons who enjoy law dramas may also be interested in Public Defender. Highly Recommended.
Where does this documentary belong on public library shelves?
Public Defender is a versatile documentary that can appeal to different audiences depending on the community it serves. If your public library caters to a community with broadly liberal views, consider placing the documentary on the political documentary shelves. The film’s examination of the legal and moral complexities faced by a public defender during the politically charged aftermath of January 6th would resonate well with audiences interested in political and social issues. However, if your library serves a more diverse or politically neutral community, the documentary would be best placed among law documentaries. Its focus on the legal process and the challenges faced by defense lawyers, particularly in high-profile and contentious cases, makes it an excellent resource for those interested in the legal system, irrespective of their political leanings.
What kind of college instructor could use this title?
Public Defender would be an invaluable educational resource for college instructors teaching introductory law courses. The documentary provides a rare and intimate look at the moral and political challenges that public defenders in America face, making it an ideal case study for students beginning their legal education. Professors could use this film to start discussions on the ethical dilemmas of defending clients involved in politically charged cases, the role of personal beliefs in the practice of law, and the impact of societal divisions on the legal system. Additionally, instructors in courses focused on political science, ethics, or American studies might also find the documentary useful for exploring broader themes of justice, democracy, and the legal implications of political movements.
What is the current pricing for educational institutions interested in this film?
$199