Misconceptions About 12 Step Programs

Buried behind about fifteen minutes worth of truly labored skits lies three minutes of information that would be useful to people with substance abuse problems (particularly alcohol), who are considering attending Alcoholics Anonymous meetings. Using a framing device featuring a moderator and a group of people who share their concerns and worries about AA meetings, the program dispels myths in a number of areas, including: mandatory speaking (not), sponsorship, rituals (not in the common sense), and fears of racial stereotyping. While the reassurances offered in each of these areas are sound, the accompanying skits (good cop/bad cop, a Marx Bros. routine, etc.) go on much too long for a tape whose primary purpose (and area of expertise) is not comedy. In addition, the program has nothing to say about the singlemost mentioned aspect of AA, the religious overtones of the "higher power" invoked in the serenity prayer (although I have to be honest and say that most of what I know about self-help meetings comes from watching Fight Club). The "higher power" issue and others are addressed, however, in the accompanying "facilitator's guide," which, as we all know, could disappear after the first circulation. While a really good affordable program on this topic would be a truly welcome addition, I'm not convinced that this is the one. Optional. Aud: P. (R. Pitman)